This paper was Presented to Maryknoll Institute Of African studies in The course of African Christian Theology Offered by Dr Julius Murikwa.It can be reached at The Institute's Library In Nairobi.
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The mission of the Lord Jesus Christ was to free the oppressed and empower them. Contrary to Jewish culture, Jesus spoke to women who were regarded as people of lower class. He liberated them from bondage of cultural constrains which oppressed and humiliated their personalities. Jesus never discriminated women, instead he gave them privilege and status. He uplifted them. However the liberation and empowerment, which Jesus gave to women, is robbed of by male dominated cultures. This cause many African women to remain victims of oppression, subjugation, discrimination and violence.
Despite of their immense contribution to both economic, political and theological development of their communities, women still remain marginalized and their efforts are unrecognized and not appreciated.
Though many resolutions such as United Nations Convention on Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) 1979, Nairobi Declaration, 1985, Beijing Action Programme 1995 and several United Declarations on the Elimination of Violence Against Women since 1993, African Women are still experiencing oppression, humiliation, subjugation, injustices and violation of their dignity and rights in excuse of culture.
Last year the United Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan said “I can not think of a single issue in the news that is not Woman’s Issue” (Daily Nation Friday, March 3, 2004). This is true because in our media everyday there are issues on violence against women. It is hard to read a full newspaper without encountering a story or an article on violence against women. This shows how serious women issues are in contemporary African World.
Many Women activists and women groups such as Eastern and Central Africa Women–in-Development Network (ECA WIDNET), coalition on violence against women (COVAW), Women Fighting AIDS in Kenya (WOFAK), Federation of Women Lawyers (FIDA) and justice and peace commission of Association of sisterhood in Kenya have been fighting on oppression, segregation, humiliation, dehumanization and violence against women by using social, legal and psychological approaches. On this work we will see how Gospel has been used by contemporary African Women to fight against oppression and violence they encounter in their daily life. We shall look on how the discrimination against women in Africa which has rendered them voiceless, powerless and inferior can be approached theologically. This will be centered on the Devine teaching that man and women were both created in the image and likeness of God and hence they have equal dignity and rights (Gen 1:27). Also the liberative mission of Jesus will not be left out as one of important Gospel approach to violence against women.
We shall see how African Christian Women are responding theologically to inequality, marginalization, discrimination and violence imposed on them by culture, laws and religion which operate on patriarchal ways. This theological approach is important because it penetrates the whole life of women affected.
1.1. Objectives
The objective of this paper is to investigate, describe and discuss theologically in inequality, marginalization, oppression, discrimination, subjugation and violence imposed to them by male dominated systems, culture and laws.
In order to observe clearly on how African Christians women struggle against violence, we will have to find out what is African Christian theology in their perspective. We will see how African Christian Women understand African Christian theology. Also we shall see how African Christian women respond to physical, psychological, social, economical and political forms of violence they face in their daily life. Here we will look at Christian faith as a tool used by African women to respond to these forms of violence.
In addition, the paper is aiming at investigating and researching on the use of Bible as a tool for fighting violence. We will try to see how Bible can be used as a tool to empower women in their struggle for liberation.
1.2. Methodology
In order to reach the aimed objectives, I have tried to use different research methodologies in this work. I have done personal in depth interviews with people of different Christian churches, ages, nationalities and different education levels at Nairobi, Nakuru, Kiambu and Nanyuki. My informants were from both mainline churches and small denominations. They were mainly from Kenya, Tanzania, Malawi and Uganda. We discussed different issues related to the topic of the study which was helpful in gathering necessary primary data and information for this paper. Some names of the informants will not be given in this work for confidential reasons. However some names of the interviewee will be directly used.
I also deepen the research of this paper by engaging in participation observation. I attended mass, prayer services, conferences and women groups meeting to observe how African Christian women are actively responding to different problems they are facing. I witnessed several initiatives of African Christian women solving their problems.
In addition, Library research acted as secondary source to my research. Course lectures on African Christian Theology gave me new ways of approaching the topic and acted as compass for the direction of the research.
1:3 Limitations
Because of short time, my field research was limited to some few selected areas in Nairobi, Kikuyu, Nakuru and Nanyuki. Sometimes language was a problem for some of the informants. They did not know Kiswahili nor English. This makes my research difficult because I didn’t know exactly the language of the informants. The work selected few theological reflections of African Women towards different forms of violence as pointers for the justification of the study because violence against women is a wide topic which cannot be thoroughly explained and discussed in the small work like this. So, further deep research can be done in future.
The research findings which will follow in the next few pages will then focus on what is African Christian Theology in African women perspective. Then we shall see African Christian women responding to different forms of violence. Also the use of the bible as a tool for women liberation will be underlined in research findings.
2.RESEARCH FINDINGS
2.1.AFRICAN CHRISTIAN THEOLOGY DEFINED IN WOMEN’S PERSPECTIVE
Many people have tried to define African Christian theology in different ways. Some have defined it as inculturation, theology contextualized in African reality, liberation theology or black theology. Women have their own perspective in defining what theology is. When I asked a middle aged Christian woman in Muguga ACK parish church on what is African Christian Theology, she said that it is expression of Christian faith in response to contemporary African experiences and problems. She said:
If Christianity wants to be relevant to present African realities, it should address contemporary problems like poverty, hunger, diseases like AIDS, unemployment and injustices like violence against women. Education is the best tool which Christianity can use to help people to Struggle out of this dehumanizing situation (Field Research Notes, 1.)
For her African Christian theology is Christian faith relevant to African situation. This faith will help African Christians to encounter and face contemporary African realities.
Another woman had the same view, for her African Christian theology is a theology reflected in such a way that it gives the marginalized people especially African women, courage, strong determination, inner strength and power to come out of humiliation and oppression. For her African Christian theology is a practical faith that will help the oppressed especially women to come out of economic, cultural, political and social injustices. (Field Research Notes, 2).
She said that traditionally African women have been looked down as passive second class beings without equal rights to those of men. So, African Christian theology is a theology that does not exclude women because God is inclusive. It is a theology that addresses issues of injustices, oppression and violence against women. This theology dignifies African Women by defending personal dignity and rights to all people because they are creatures of universal God.
According to her, Christianity had come with Western culture which silenced African women. It encouraged men to study and be in pulpits preaching while women remained passive spectators in matters concerning Christian faith. Now African Christian theology should be a reflection of faith which includes women as equal co-reflectors.
Sr. Lukresia said that African Christian theology is theology that restores the dignity of African women by freeing her from rape, marginalization, oppression, harassment and suppression. For her “African Christian theology is a theology which frees African women from domination of male dominated oppressive cultural practices and customs which violates their rights and dignity”. (Field Research Notes, 4).
She stressed that African Christian Theology must address male dominated structures both outside and inside the church. It is a theology that challenges critically and objectively the use of God, religious doctrines and bible to justify women’s subjugation, dehumanization and oppression. Through this theology African Christian women are challenged to take bold steps to refuse this subjugation, oppression, discrimination, exclusion and marginalization in both society and the church.
In other words African Christian theology should help women to analyze, reflect and transform the male dominated Christianity into authentic African Christianity lived in joy and peace. This is faith expressed in healing the deep and painful wounds that have divided the African society by subjugating and discriminating women. This theology considers both women and men in its approach rather than being male dominated reflection of Christian faith.
The above description shows clearly that African Christian theology should not be abstract principles, dogmas, doctrines and creeds. It should be faith lived practically in African Context. “Theologizing in African context is living Christian faith in concrete situations. By doing that, Christian faith becomes practical when it is contextualized within African milieu”. (Field Research Notes, 2).
According to one informant, Western theology had maintained patriarchal tradition which denied dignity, rights and responsibility to women. African culture has been used as a tool to perpetuate the oppression of women even in theological matters. Now African Christian theology should dismantle patriarchal tradition and try to formulate the theology which is both African and Christian and which maintains the dignity of all people as equal creatures from God’s hands. (Field Research Notes, 3).
So, African Christian theology is a reflection of Christian faith that generates a rebellion and fight against customs, traditions, beliefs and doctrines that oppress the marginalized in the society. This theology generates new faith in God who is universal, just, love and liberator. This theology uses the bible which is the word of God to humanize, divinize and vitalize those oppressive aspects of African culture. By this way the gospel becomes incarnate in the struggle for freedom of humanity.
Sr. Mary concurs to above argument by saying that African Christian theology is a theology which stops male chauvinism and discourage those taboos which dehumanize and act as stumbling blocks in the well being of women, while at the same time encourages and champions those taboos that promote the well being of women. For her, the gospel can transcend all customs, taboos and traditions that oppress women by challenging them critically destructing the liberative ones. (Field Research Notes, 4).
An old Kikuyu woman at Nanyuki said in Kikuyu:
Ukirithihano ni watigithukanirie andu handu na kunyutithania atheru na matari atheru athomu na matathomete. Ukirithiano nduigana kuhe atimia riri wao. Nduigana kumahe kahinda ga kunyitanira thiini wa Kanitha an njira igivete (Field Research Notes, 10).
Literally, meaning that Christianity has separated people as holy and unholy, pagan and baptized, learned and unlearned, superior and inferior, instead of uniting them all. It never gave women their dignity. It also never gave them a chance to participate fully in church.
So, in contemporary African Christianity, African Christian theology should be a theology that recognizes the knowledge, gifts, creativity, talents and institution of women and give them opportunity to share those gifts. African Christian theology should recognize and encourage women’s call and make women feel that they have an essential role of establishing peaceful and justify kingdom of God in African. This theology should redeem women from patriarchal captivity of the western church that undermines the role played by women in salvation history. However, by doing so the church must have the theological will to provide women with the opportunity.
Another informant supports the above description by lamenting that Western Christian theology came with arrogant western culture which eroded African culture by diving people. It dichotomized people. She go on saying that the ethnic conflicts we have today in African countries like Rwanda and Burundi are the consequences of western Christianity which used the method of divide and rule to get followers. As a result women and children are suffering. Because of wars, women are now victims of sexual abuse, diseases and poverty. Now in Africa we need a Christian theology that will cut across ethnic boundaries and unite all people in peacefully one big family. This theology must reflect peace and reconciliation and includes women as main players in building the kingdom of God which is peaceful and lovely. (Field Research Notes, 3).
For her African Christian theology is a theology of peace and reconciliation. It is theology that encourages people from different ethnic groups, races and genders to appreciate each other and respect one another as children of one God though they are different. This theology does not exclude anyone but all inclusive.
2.2 AFRICAN CHRISTIAN WOMEN RESPONDING TO DIFFERENT
FORMS OF VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN
As we have seen in the prior section, different women have shown that African Christian theology should be a theology that eradicates injustices, oppression, inequality, discrimination and violence which cause suffering and violates the rights and dignity of women. Majority of African women are victims of abuse, suffering and mistreatment. These violence generally are done to women with the intention of hurting them simply because they are women. This violence take different forms like physical violence such as beatings, slapping, punching and circumcision, psychological violence such as verbal abuse, greater appreciation of boys than girls, fear of being attacked, beaten or harassed, husbands restricting their wives movements etc. Also in the field research I have discovered political, economical and social violence which include cultural, sexual and domestic violence. Generally violence against women takes many forms. However I have tried to classify the findings in the forms below.
2.2.1 Physical Violence
Physical violence are actions that harms the body or biological makeup of the one affected. According to Dr. Euphigenia Gachiri, female circumcision is a greatest violence against women because it affects the women physically, psychologically and socially. It is violation of women rights in the highest order. It reduces function of the beautiful body created by God. Circumcised women will not enjoy sexual act which is sacred. Women are usually traumatized, become sick and eventually die. To her this is a big sin which should be addressed by the church because of the harm it causes to women.
She said ignorance causes hundreds of Christian girls go through female circumcision. Both girls and parents are not aware of negative effects of female circumcision. Some Christians even use the bible to defend female circumcision (Field Research Notes, 9).
According to Dr. Gachiri there are a lot of myths surrounding female circumcision. Some say that God does not hear the prayer of uncircumcised woman because she does not belong to God as she is unclean, dirty and outcast. To circumcise is to clean and purify the woman. Some people think if a woman is not circumcised the clitoris will prolong and so the women will fail to give birth. Others think that circumcision is just like tattooing and so they don’t see why one should stop the parents from tattooing their children. She said that these people believe in these myths and legends because the church has not addressed them. The people want to hear what the teaching of the church on this issue is.
Though some church leaders are not very supportive of the fight against female circumcision some leaders have addressed the act as sinful evil which dehumanize women. For effective termination of female circumcision she recommends, the need for more involvement of church leaders, opinion leaders, women and men leaders. She said the gospel should strongly address the problem by evolving alternative rite of passage for girls which is more human, African and Christian.
Another informant said female genital mutilation is violation of God’s creation. God has created every organ for a purpose. No any organ which has no use. External genitalia are important in physiology. When clitoris is damaged then sexual response impaired because is there fore sexual enjoyment purpose. These cause women to face difficulties during sexual intercourse. Why should women made to suffer by being circumcised? She said that African Christian theology should co sensitize Christians on the role of each body organ according to God’s plan. It should educate people that nobody has a right to destroy any body organ except God who created it. African men should be made aware that African women cannot be controlled sexually by being circumcised but rather they can control themselves because they have been given will, conscience and freedom by God just like men (FR# 5).
According to one informant, naïve reasons given for female genital mutilation as customary, religious, purification, prevention of promiscuity, hygiene and protection of virginity should be challenged by the gospel. The gospel should radiates this act and come out with alternative African rite which should also enhance sense of belonging, bring in religious purification, dignifies the initiates and brings sense of faithfulness. Generally this rite enlightened by gospel should form the initiates morally, spiritually, psychologically and intellectually instead of traumatize and dehumanize them (Field Research Notes,5).
Another form of physical violence which lowers dignity of women is wife beating. This is very common form of violence. This is always in form of slapping, hitting, pulling and beating. One informant who is a single mother living at Nakuru slums said that she was pulled and beaten by her husband simply because she attended choir practices in the church. Her husband used cane to beat her badly. She shows me the scar of the wound on the left leg which was caused by beatings from he husband. She said that when she complained to her in-laws they told her that she is supposed to be submissive to her husband because that is what the bible says. She said:
They said the bible advises wives to be submissive to their husbands as a sign of love. Then I decided to report the case to the priest but she encouraged me to forgive my husband and persevere in marriage relationship because that is my cross. I was fearing to leave my husband because of love to my children. I could not leave them. However my husband continued to abuse me verbally, so I decided to leave because I could not continue to live in that humiliation. I am living happily because my church women members support me. Together we draw energy from Jesus to cope with our problems. (Field Research Notes, 7).
Another woman said that she was beaten by her husband when she was pregnant and she had miscarried. This affected her up to today because she cannot have more children as her womb was affected. She said:
For long time I have been feeling worthless in front of others but I have been helped by Christian women counseling organization and now I see myself as full human being with dignity. The prayer group has been giving me courage and power to go on without remembering the past. I have forgiven my husband totally and now I live a happy life full of joy from Jesus my Savior and Lord (Field Research Notes, 7).
The informants had the view that people should accept the gospel and Jesus as their power and strength and then they will not follow traditions, culture and myths that perpetuate wife beatings. In Jesus there are no wife beatings because it is his love which radiates family life.
2:2:2.Psychological Violence
Psychological violence is any act or statement made to divert, falsify, oppress attack or alienate woman’s way of thinking, reasoning, understanding and behaving. In psychological violence women are tortured verbally. These acts can harm, disturb and destabilize the personality and generally the whole life of the woman.
One informant said that women are always subjected to psychological and emotional torture through insults, offensive words and taboos. These actions downplay the status of women in the society. For instance she said that women are always portrayed negatively as weak beings. A boy will always be told “be strong, don’t be weak like a woman, or don’t cry like a woman, don’t gossip like a woman. In schools teachers will mock boys who are defeated by girls in class. Girls who do well are described as masculine. In work women who do tough work like engineering, architecture and preaching are considered tough like men” (Field Research Notes, 7). All these make women feel inferior to men. They lower their self-esteem.
To remove this situation, Christian faith should try to inculcate the gospel values of equality and sense of dignity as they are portrayed in creation history in the bible and liberative mission of Jesus. In other words, African Christian theology which is the fruit of the gospel should try to eliminate taboos, myths and beliefs which affect women mentally and psychologically. It should uplift women by giving them confidence to assert themselves.
2:2:3: Political and Economical Violence
One woman told me that in politics women who want to be politicians should be ready to be publicly humiliated. They should be ready to be called prostitutes. In politics abusive language is used deliberately against women to humiliate them, degrade them and deprive them of their human dignity and rights. When women win in election always people will say that they have manipulated men outside their marriage to wine the election (Field Research Notes, 8).
Another woman said:
It is tough being a woman in politics. People think that women cannot make good political leaders. Women are intimidated. They think it is not easy for women to participate in higher level decision making meetings. It is absurd even women are reluctant to elect their fellow women as representatives in politics and sometimes even in church leadership. Men leaders and even some women tend to believe that men have been endowed power by God to control and lead women. They think women are not talented by God to be leaders (Field Research Notes, 8).
For her, Christian faith should help African women to discover their talents and therefore affirm themselves as creatures created by God just as men. African Christians should understand that women are human created in the image and likeness of God just like men and so they ought to enjoy fairness, equality and justice for that is what the gospel message portrayed in Christianity teaches. She went on saying that African women politicians should draw their strength form their Christian faith. This is true because I have observed that members of Catholic Women Association (CWA) are encouraged to have political awareness and to participate in politics.
Economically, many women contribute much in acquisition of family property. However after the death of their husbands they are deprived of their right to inherit those properties. Are they not persons who have rights like men? The gospel should give African Christian women voice to stand firm in fighting for their inheritance rights. The gospel should make them stop from merely complaining about their material and economic deprivation instead of taking firm control of their own economic fate.
To affirm the above stand one informant told me:
I was selling sukuma while my husband works with one manufacturing company in the industrial area. We have four children who are schooling. I am the pillar of the family because I sustain my family in everything. My husband spends his money on beer and girlfriends instead of supporting our children in food and school fees. I am the one who even pays house rent through my little business. However my husband counts everything I bought as his. I don’t care much as I am happy because in the church together with other women we have our women group which supports us. The group becomes at reservoir where we draw strength, inspiration, companionship and support. The gospel we read supports and encourages us. The group helps us in economic activities for self reliance. With our motto “strong in faith” we strongly get faith which we greatly need in order to withstand the ups and downs of our daily family life. Sometimes the group gets the chance to impart Christian principles of equality and justice to men by giving seminars and workshops to married couples (Field Research Notes, 8).
So, African men should be challenged by the gospel to respect women’s inheritance rights. They should take into consideration the gospel truth that regardless of gender, both women and men are given equal rights to use and own earthly resources. The Christian principles of equality and justice should reign in married couples.
2:2:4: Social Violence
Social violence can either be cultural, sexual or domestic. These are violation of cultural, sexual, domestic rights and dignity of women. Most of the time African culture gives menthe right to be superior over men. This culture institutionalizes some forms of violence such as wife beating, female genital mutilation, violence related to inheritance, rape and discrimination of girls. One woman who is a single mother living at Nakuru said that single mothers are always victims of deprivation, exploitation, oppression, violence, discrimination, stigma and malicious accusations. People have prejudices and biases against single mothers. People saw them as prostitutes and irresponsible adults. The woman said “They do not know we (single mothers) are too humans who need to be given chance, rights and dignity just like men. We deserve opportunity, honor, dignity and appreciation. We are Gods creatures just like other human beings”. (Field Research Notes, 7)
Speaking about cultural oppression, another woman said that some cultural taboos are very oppressive to us women. She challenged, “Why for example women should be forbidden to eat some foods such as eggs or liver? Is there any food created by God for men alone?” For her, the bible gives all plants and animals to both men and women for food. “Again, why widow should be forcibly inherited? Why shouldn’t they be left to decide their own fate! Are they not human beings who have been endowed with intelligence by God to decide and judge?” The woman challenged African Christians should move a step forward by the help of gospel to challenge these cultural taboos, customs and beliefs which oppress women (Field Research Notes, 8).
The argument above was supported by a Luhya Christian woman who said that according to Luhya customs she is discriminated because she is not married. She said that not to be married in Luhya custom is considered as a kind of insult to ones parents. She said “my parents want me to be married. Now they are unhappy because I have two children but I am not married. At the beginning I was sad but now I am happy because I have drawn strength and energy from Jesus Christ who talked to me the way He talked to the sinful woman and the Samaritan woman.”(Field Research Notes, 7).According to her though it was against Jewish customs and traditions, Jesus talked to women who were considered inferior and encouraged them. She said, “I am happy because Jesus is my hope, salvation and liberation. I don’t have any worry to break any taboo” (Field Research Notes, 7).
Again, culturally, in most of African communities boys are given priority in education than girls. Girls are always the first one to wake up at home to do domestic chores and last to sleep while boys enjoy sleeping. In schools girls are harassed by male teachers. Male teachers take sexual advantage over girls. This is sexual violence.
Speaking about sexual violence one woman said that it is sexual assault by force without the consent of the woman. This includes rape, defilement which dehumanizes women. She said, one day a case was brought to her of one girl who was walking in Kibera slums and then she was kissed and touched in her sexual organs by one man against her will. For her this was sexual abuse and sin because it dehumanized the girl. It is against God’s commandment of love (Field Research Notes, 8).
She said that thousands of girls and women have been robbed of their dignity and rights by rapists. Physical force applied during raping and sex lowers the dignity of women. The church by the power of gospel tries to help several African women who have been sexually abused and now suffering silently as they struggle to overcome traumatic experience. Men should be challenged by the gospel to regard women as equal partners in sexual matters.
Christianity is making women to be aware of their rights as human beings. The gospel enlightens them to be ready to reveal their problems instead of hiding them. The gospel makes women to say no to invasion of their bodies by force because their bodies are temples of the Holy Spirit.
The gospel invites African Christians to struggle against violence by adopting a firm but gentle stand against injustices and violation of human rights. The gospel invites Africans do denounce and combat all that degrades and destroys the human person. The gospel should help Christians to overcome violence by love, justice and peace which are gospel principles.
2:3:BIBLE AS A WEAPON ON VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN
The creation account shows clearly that men and women were created in the image of God. The bible portrays many women who were the shareholders in the salvation history. However in the field I got two reactions on bible. The first reaction is supportive of bible as a tool for women liberation while the other side views the bible as an ideological tool to oppress women. Generally, there are those who see it as oppressive and those who view it as liberative.
One woman aid that bible has been used as a tool for gender segregation. Many men use bible to legitimize their oppression to women. Always they use the bible to defend their superiority and authority over women. Instead of it being used to combat oppression and violence against women is used to support those evil acts. For her bible should be retranslated and interpreted to eliminate sexism, discrimination and oppression attitudes. (Field Research Notes, 6).
Another woman is of the same view by saying that bible is the product of men because it was men who compiled and translated it. Men interpret the Holy Scriptures in favors of oppression of women. At times they use some biblical passages which are based on Jewish culture to defend the subjugation for women. The role of women as partners in the history of salvation as it is described in the bible is not noticed by men. Women should reclaim the bible and make it theirs by studying, reading and reflecting on it (Field Research Notes, 6).
On the other hand, liberative view of the bible is the use of biblical texts, parables, stories and figures for searching of dignity and emancipation of women. There are many extemporary women like Mary mother of Jesus, Elizabeth, Anne, Martha, Judith, Esther and Mary Magdalene who can act as models for African women struggling to eliminate violence against them (Field Research Notes, 6).
2:4:JESUS THE HELPER IN CURBING VIOLENCE
Biblically, Jesus contrary to Jewish and even African culture elevated the position of women. He respected and dignified them. As we have seen; His mission was to set free those who were oppressed including women.
In the field many African Christian women depicted Jesus as the liberator of African women from taboos which restrict their participation in the community life (Field Research Notes, 9). Jesus is described by African Christian women as the liberator from oppressive customs and traditions. For them Jesus never excluded women, He was the message of liberation for them.
One woman described Jesus as strength, Savior, hope, model, helper and teacher in her life (Field Research Notes, 8). Another one said that Jesus is a friend, supporter, mother, Savoir, Protector one who solves problems and the one who gives strength. For her, faith in Jesus gives her strength. Her personal relationship with Jesus has been source of life giving comfort and strength. (Field Research Notes, 8).
African Christian women looked at Jesus as the one who empowers women to reject violence. They see Jesus as the one who takes weakness, misery, injustice and oppression. They take Jesus to be the one who shares in their sorrows and sadness when they are in troubles and difficulties.
This is because from his birth in Nazareth to his resurrection including his death on the cross, Jesus was always accompanied and attended by women. Women were the first to receive the news of resurrection. This is hope for women. Resurrection is new life to women.
Many women, in my field research said that in Jesus they feel secure, so good, uplifted and comfort. In Jesus they get energy to overcome their problems. They said that many women hide their problems with regard to violence because of fear and also for the reason of protecting their husbands’ good name and image. Some are reluctant to report the abuse because of fear of being stigmatized. However in Jesus they are forced to share with pastors and other members and so they are set free. For them Jesus is the one set them free.
3.LITERATURE REVIEW
3.1: Gospel as a challenge to oppressive traditions and customs
In African culture a woman was given a special place of honor as the mother of the society. She was treated as custodian of life and the culture of the society. In African traditional religion women were priestesses who co-officiate at community rituals and sacrifices. They were healers, diviners, mediums and community elders. However as we have seen in the research findings Christianity has not brought substantial changes. This is spelled out clearly by Alina (1990):
Although Christianity has long been experienced in African and has preached that Jesus Christ came to liberate everybody irrespective of sex, race, strength or financial status, African women have been locked up in a safe compartment together with their good ideas. (P. 31).
African women are still oppressed and humiliated by taboos which affect their well being socially, economically, politically and spiritually. The Ugandan theologian, Mpagi (2002), in his book African Christian Theology: In the contemporary Context says that:
The taboos have both positive and negative effect to women. For him taboos did and continue to hinder the well being of women and do not allow them to enjoy life in all its fullness. While some bring out social order, control behavior and regulate misconduct in the society, other taboos enslave people by creating far, retard reasoning, block creativity hinder personal initiative, show down development and reduce women to the levels which deny women the abundant life that God intended (Pp. 175-176).
Again, in African literature there are many taboos, proverbs, poems, plays, films, sayings and remarks that support oppression and violence against women. African oral literature portrays women negatively as possession of men, unclean, unthinkable, irresponsible and delicate. This causes women to be regarded as weaker sex. This attitude furls violence against women which “is worldwide phenomenon” (cf Wasike 2005, p120).
As it is stated in Violence Against Women Trainers Manual (1997), these violence has physical, psychological and spiritual effects on women. Psychologically, women may live under intense fear. They may not be confidence to express their faith, feelings and talents. This was clearly spelt out by the women I interviewed. Some women affected by violence were feeling shy and abnormal until they came under faith groups and church organizations where they get strength and energy to cope with their situations. (Field Research Notes, 8)
As we have seen women are segregated in the society even in the church. I agree with Oduyoye (2001), in her work Introducing African Women’s Theology, that often the language of the church puts women down. Their power is denied and their experiences rejected. Very often they work in the church and men take credit for the outcome. Their work is not seen because they are regarded as weak (9. 82). Again the same theologian in her book, Hearing and Knowing: Theological Reflection on Christianity in Africa (1986) said “the women are very much concerned about the church but the church is not so much concerned about women” (p.124).
So, the gospel should challenge all patriarchal systems in the church and society in general to accept women as co-workers in evangelization process. African Christians should take the challenge of justice and equality as it is underlined in the gospel.
3:2.Solutions to Violence against Women
To solve the problem of violence against women the Kenyan Professor, Hinga (2005) suggests:
Women should re-educate themselves to learn to take the bull by the horn and decide to fight back, not necessarily physically since this way they cannot win but creating institutions and avenues that enhance their self esteem and confidence as women (P. 152).
As we have seen from research findings female circumcision is the greatest violence against women that affect women psychologically, physically and spiritually.
Gachiri (2000) in her book Female Circumcision says “the most devastating effect of circumcision on a woman is that it changes the woman’s body and its purposes from the way God made it” (p.132). This means that female circumcision is against God’s plan. It reduces and deprives women of their God’s given rights and duties as mothers and wives. It makes them objects. In the video, As beautiful as God made me: Say No to female circumcision, The Catholic Archbishop of Nairobi, Rafael Ndingi Mwana’anzeki said that female circumcision has no religious base. It is just subjugation of women by men.
The above explanation shows clearly that female circumcision is dehumanizing act which should not be totally tolerated by the gospel. It the task of the gospel to shade light to African Christians on the negative ness and badness of the female circumcision. African Christian should be challenged to look at female circumcision critically and weigh out the advantages and disadvantages of it. This will help them to stop this oppressive and dehumanizing custom.
Again Gachiri (2000) puts it clearly that “effective termination of female circumcision needs more active involvement of church personnel than seem to be happening at the moment”. (P.126).
Writing about the cure to the problems of women, Carole Rabyburn (1993) quoted a catholic nun Martha Kirk who said that “until woman assumes her rightful place in Christian ministry, Christ has only one hand with which to heal, to strengthen, to touch and to console” (p.124).
This shows that women need to claim their presence and position in the church as partners in spiritual and theological matters. Unless they are included as disciples and instruments of goods news of gospel then Christianity in Africa is incomplete. So, African Christian theology should be inclusive and not only men’s project.
3:3.Church response to Violence against Women
The church is not quite in women issues. It has taken step and supports women’s effort to assert their dignity as person’s created by God. In the second Vatican council which was convened by Pope John XXII in 1959, the leaders of the church were argued to re-evaluate the status of women in the church in the light of contemporary scholarly information. The council affirms that women had a right and freedom which had hitherto been denied. The council encouraged women’s desire to play the vital role in the church and society at large. (Vatican II Documents. 267).
These documents are very powerful resources which empower women to combat violence. However, the documents are left to be covered with dust and cob-webs in the libraries. The efforts to put them in practice are very low and slow.
Writing about the church in Africa, in post-ynodal Apostolic Exhortation: The church in Africa, Pope John Paul II (1995) emphasizes the dignity and rights of the African Women by saying that “One of the characteristic signs of our times is the growing awareness of women’s dignity and their specific role in the society at large……..I have repeatedly affirmed the fundamental equality and enriching complimentarily that exists between man and woman”. (No. 121).
By the words of Pope John Paul II, African synod of Bishops, support liberation of women. The synod condemns oppression and discrimination existing in Africa. The Pope (1995) condemns violence in Africa by saying that the church deplores and condemns the customs and practices which deprive women of their rights and respect due to them (No. 121).
However, ten years after the synod of Africa, not much has been done by the African Church to empower African Women practically. Women are still segregated and discriminated in political, social and even religious arenas. Their rights are still violated. Though they are doing marvelous job in both social and religious dimensions, their contribution is still not recognized.
The church renews its support for elimination of oppression and violence against women. In the Association of member Episcopal conferences of Eastern Africa (AMECEA) 14TH plenary in Dar-es-Salaam Tanzania (July 14th to 28th 2002) more than 70 catholic Bishops from Ethiopia, Eritrea, Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania, Malawi and Zambia condemned oppressive cultural practices and customs.
In their final address to all people of God in their own countries they said:
We strongly condemn the oppressive cultural practices and customs which violate the equal dignity and rights of sections of God’s people in the region. We call upon our governments, entire civil society and all our pastoral agents to join us in total elimination of Female Genital Mutilation (FGM), the commercialization of “bride wealth”, domestic violence against women, abuse of patriarchalism to discriminate against women, the practices of widow inheritance and exclusion of women from property ownership. (AMECEA 14th Plenary Statement of Bishop signed by Arch Bishop Bakyenga of Masaka).
In his encyclical letter, Dignity and Vocation of Women (1988), Pope John Paul shows great appreciation to women. He takes Mary Mother of Jesus as the model to faith, charity, and perfect union with Christ. He said Mary was important figure in the event of salvation. So, African women are called to imitate Mary. At Nanyuki, the African Bible on the Ground Benedictine Monastery I saw a very big portrait of Blessed Virgin Mary with the following words which are very beautiful to an African woman:
An African woman like Mary is prayerful
An African woman like Mary is obedient
An African woman like Mary is faithful
An African woman like Mary is content with little
An African woman like Mary is hospitable
An African woman like Mary is transparent
An African woman like Mary is hard working
An African woman like Mary is unifying factor
An African woman like Mary is merciful
An African woman like Mary is looking ahead (Field Research Notes, 10)
These words show the virtues of an African Woman which are to be propagated by any African Christian woman. Through cultivation of these virtues African women will be firm to face violence and injustices done to them. They will be ready to be good messengers of the Gospel. By living those virtues African Christian women will be exemplary for other women fighting against violence inflicted on them. As Mary virtuous life was rooted in Strong faith, also African Christian women should root their struggle against violence on the firm Christian faith.
Traditionally, African women have been custodians of life, sustainers of the community, transmitters of life and upholders of culture. So the gospel should transform violence, poverty, exploitation, dehumanization, sexism and oppression so as to let African women regain their former values, duties and responsibilities. This is what African Christian women need. They need to regain their rightful place given by God in the Bible. (Genesis chapter 1).
4:CONCLUSION:
As we have seen, African women experience different forms of injustices like painful clitoridectomy, rape, force widow inheritance, prostitution, child marriage and discrimination in education and employment. Male chauvinism is reigning in every situation of women life. We have seen how women are struggling to resolve this dehumanizing situation. However women should make sure that the key struggle in women emancipation movement should not be lost in their emotions. Their struggle against violence must never be rooted in anger but love. The struggle should go deep instead of advocating simple things like putting on male clothes by women, divorce and avoiding kitchen work.
The gospel should be read reflectively and critically to draw strength for the deep struggle on violence against women. The gospel should help the down trodden women to stand erect. It should knock down the walls that separate the members of the society in order to build a church which is a communion in one family irrespective of gender.
However African Christian women should not be mere observers and victims of oppressive culture but cultural architects and gospel agents in their own right, reclaim their rightful role in the cultural reconstruction of more authentic, lovely and justfuly patterns of living. To do this the gospel must change all aspects of life.
As oppression and violence against women is a reality in Africa, African woman should be aware of the situation and start liberating herself. She should not wait for liberation to be given to her as a bundle of roses. She should struggle to be liberated by acquiring education which is a basic fool for liberation. However secular education is not enough to empower African women spiritually. African women should do further studies in Bible, theology, spirituality and church law so that they may be well equipped fully to articulate the feminine nature in Christianity.
Also every African Christian should remember that both man and woman were both created in God’s image. “Male and female he created them” (Gen 1:27) and so everyone has equal dignity and rights irrespective of his or her gender. Christians must know that the only way to realize gender equality is through working together to remove injustices, oppressions and discriminations. By working in partnership of women and men then African Christians can create a just and fair environment which is less of violence against women. God has no gender, God is inclusive is both our mother and our father. So, African Christian Theology should neither be feminist oriented nor male oriented. It should be a reflection of faith which includes the whole Family of God.
Field Research Summary
1. Muguga – Kiambaa. January 16, 2005. To interview 2 grass root members of Christian church on what issues they want to see Christianity address. The two Christians of A.C.K. church were very happy to share with me on the issues they want to be addressed by Christianity. They said if Christianity wants to be relevant to Africa people, it should address the present African realities and problems like poverty, hunger, diseases like AIDS, unemployment and injustices like violence against women. One informant said there are alot of inequalities and oppression which Christianity should address. Another informant suggested that education is the best tool which Christianity can use to help people to struggle out of the dehumanizing situation.
2. Karen, Nairobi. January 17, 2005. To interview two professional Christian women on what they think is African Christian theology. They were very open and articulate in sharing with me what is African Christian theology. One woman said African Christian theology is a theology reflected in such a way it gives the marginalized people especially African women, courage, inner strength and power to come out of humiliation and oppression. Another one said that theologizing in African context is living Christian faith in concrete situations. For her it is not going to church every Sunday but rather being changed by the gospel and think in human way under the inspiration of God.
3. Baba Dogo, Nairobi. January 23, 2005. To attend a service at the Independent Church, and observe the involvement of women, and interview several on violence against women. One woman who is a refugee from Rwanda said wars cause a lot of violence to women. For her, Western Christianity has divided people. African Christian theology should be a theology of peace which brings all people together. Other women said that Western theology has maintained patriarchal tradition which denied dignity to women. African Christian theology should dismantle this patriarchal tradition and formulate theology which is both Africa and Christian.
4. Bogani – Langata, Nairobi. February 5, 2005. To interview 2 religious women on the role and place of women in the church. Sr. Lucresia said that women are majority in the church. They are doing a lot but sometimes they ignored by men members of the church. For her, African Christian theology should restore the dignity of African Women and make them more active participants in the activities. Women are good instruments of good news. However she said women are not given high positions in the church. The church should empower women; it should involve women in planning, discussions and decision making. Sr. Mary said since the time of Jesus women have been instruments of spreading gospel message. However their position has been that of “silent evangelizers”. Due to African culture, traditions and taboos women are not noticed so African Christian theology should transcend all customs and create equal opportunities for both genders.
5. Wanyoro Village, Nakuru. February 13, 2005. To interview several women on their participation in the church. One woman says women are first evangelizers and so they should be given big roles in evangelization in the church. Another woman said women are marginalized, oppressed and dehumanized. They have been dehumanized and isolated by the African culture. The gospel should redeem women and cultural customs and traditions like women circumcision, wife beating and sexual harassment that oppress and dehumanize them. Another informant said women are people like men, why should they be isolated from some church activities. She said the gospel should radiate and challenges African Christian churches to work on negative aspect of African culture like genital mutilation.
6. Karen, Nairobi. February 20, 2005. To interview 3 women on how the bible can be used as a weapon on violence against women. One woman said the bible has been used by men to subjugate women. Instead of using it to combat violence against women they use it to legalize oppression attitudes. Another woman said the bible is the product of men because it was written and translated by men. On the other side another one said that the bible can be used as a tool for liberation of women. There are elements in the bible and exemplary figures that can be used as source of power for women seeking emancipation.
7. Mukuru, Nairobi. February 22, 2005. To interview women on Christian approach to violence against women. I interviewed 3 women and they were happy to share their experience with me. All of them said that wife beatings are very common in the slums. One woman said at times wife beatings end up in divorcing; when beaten women go to the church leaders they are told to persevere because that’s how marriage life is. Another woman said she has been helped by Christian women counseling group and now she is free and even she has forgiven her husband. Another woman said African oral literature portrays women negatively and so the gospel should challenge this literature.
8. Kibera, Nairobi. February 26, 2005. To investigate on African Christian women response to violence. I interviewed 3 women. One woman who is a tailor said it is difficult for African women to be a politician. If one decides to context she will not win because even her fellow women will not choose her. People think that God created men to be rulers over women. Another woman who is a teacher said women should not fear men because they are all God’s creatures. Let African women be inspired by their Christian faith and enter into politics without fear let them take Jesus as their modes and supporter. Another woman who is a social worker said that women groups are strength, inspiration and places where women affected by violence get comfort, companionship and support. Through sharing the word of God they are strengthened. Jesus becomes the hope, supporter, savior and protector.
9. Loreto Convent Msongari – Nairobi, March 1, 2005. To investigate on the efforts of the church in Africa to eradicate violence against women. In the interview, Dr. Euphgenia Gachiri the organizer and facilitator of Loreto outreach program to eradicate female circumcision said, circumcision is violence against women in the highest order. It is violation of women rights. It is spoiling of the body created by God and so it reduces the function of the body. For her effective eradication of it needs more involvement of church leaders than it used to be. Her work is to expose the reality to the people.
10. Nanyuki, Kenya. March 6, 2005. To investigate what is African Christian theology in women perspective. I attended mass at the monastery then I interviewed several women. One woman shows the distinction between Western theology which came with colonization and African Christian theology which is supposed to be practical. She said Western theology separated people but African Christian theology should unite people. Another woman said the stories of the bible should be interpreted in African realities like what Benedictine Monks are doing at Nanyuki.
Bibliography:
ALINA, M. (1990). “Jumping Culture’s Fences” in Mercy A. Oduyoye and Kanyoro (Eds). The will to Arise. Pp 131-135: New York: Orbis Books.
AYANGA, H.O. (1999). “Liberation of the African Women”. In Mary N. Getui and Emmanuel Obeng’ (Eds). Theology of Reconstruction: Exploratory Essays pp. 90-106. Nairobi: Acton.
Eastern and Central Africa Women in Development Network (Eds). (1997). Violence against Women Trainers Manual. Nairobi: Paulines Publications.
GACHIRI, E.W. (2000). Female Circumcision.Nairobi: Paulines Publications Africa.
HINGA, T.M. (2005). “Violence Against Women: A challenge to the church” in Douglas W. Watauga and Hannah Kinoti (Eds) Pastoral care in African Christianity: challenging Essays in Pastoral Theology pp 137-153. Nairobi: Acton.
JOHN PAUL II. (1988). Dignity and Vocation of women. Nairobi: Paulines Publications Africa.
JOHN PAUL II. (1995). The church in Africa: Post-synodal Apostolic Exhortation of the Holy Father to the church in Africa. Nairobi: Paulines Publication Africa.
MPAGI, P.W. (2002).African Christian Theology: In Contemporary context.Kisubi: Marianum Publishing company LTD.
ODUYOYE, M.A. (1986). Hearing and Knowing: Theological Reflections on Christianity in Africa. New York: Orbis Books.
ODUYOYE, M.A. (2001). Introducing African Women’s Theology. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press.
RABYBURN, C.A. (1993). “Return to the Dance: The power of Ritual in “Ordinary” Lives”. In Lesley A. Northup (Ed) Women and Religious Ritual. Washington DC: The Pastoral Press.
VATICAN II Documents, (1964) Dogmatic Constitution on the church (Lumen Gentium). Vatican city: AAS Vatican Council II (1965). Pastoral constitution on the church in the Modern World (Gaudium et Spes) Vatican city: AAS.
WASIKE, A.N. (2005). “Domestic Violence Against Women: A Cry for Life in wholeness”. In Douglas W. Waruta and Itannah W. Kinoti (Eds) pastoral care in African Christianity: Challenging Essays in pastoral Theology. PP 120-135. Nairobi: Acton.
Videos:
As Beautiful as God made me: say no to female circumcision. Ukweli Video Productions.
Newspapers:
Daily Nation, Friday March 3, 2004.